How Fellow Drives a 6.2% Conversion Rate with Text-to-Buy Drops
Fellow replaced a manual, error-prone text ordering process with AudienceTap’s fully automated platform — and their Fellow Drops subscribers now spend 3x more on Fellow hardware than the average customer.
6.2%
Conversion rate
vs 0.12% for SMS campaigns
$1.94
Earned per message
vs $0.13 email average
32x
ROI
3x
More spend
from Drops subscribers
About Fellow
Premium Coffee & Brewing Equipment
Fellow is a premium coffee brewing equipment company known for its design-forward products and passionate community. In 2020, Fellow launched an in-house Text-to-Buy program for their weekly coffee drops — giving subscribers first access to limited-edition single-origin roasts. The program quickly gained traction, but the manual processes behind it couldn’t keep up with demand.
A Manual Process That Couldn’t Scale
Fellow’s in-house Text-to-Buy program was gaining traction, but the manual workflow behind it was unsustainable. Every week meant late nights exporting orders, reconciling payments, and managing fulfillment by hand.
Manual fulfillment work
Every drop required evening work exporting orders, managing fulfillment, and reconciling payments — a process that grew more painful as the subscriber list scaled.
Error risks & inefficiency
Manual data entry created real risk of order errors. Internal resources were diverted from growth initiatives to keep the program running week to week.
Failed subscription model
Fellow experimented with a traditional subscription model, but high acquisition costs and poor retention made it unsustainable. They needed a better way to drive repeat purchases.
Fully Automated Text-to-Buy with AudienceTap
Fellow transitioned their Drops program to AudienceTap’s fully automated platform. Order processing, payment capture, and analytics are now handled end-to-end — freeing the team to focus on product and growth.
Automated order processing
Every drop order is captured, confirmed, and synced to Shopify automatically — no manual exports or evening work.
Integrated with existing SMS
AudienceTap layered on top of Fellow’s existing marketing workflows, adding transactional capabilities without disrupting promotional campaigns.
Comprehensive analytics
Real-time visibility into conversion rates, revenue per message, and subscriber behavior — with clear, unambiguous attribution.
Freed internal resources
The team redirected hours previously spent on manual order management toward product development and business growth.
Powered by Shopify Collective
Fellow doesn’t roast coffee. They operate as a curator brand in the specialty coffee space, partnering with roasters across the country for limited-edition drops. Shopify Collective is the infrastructure that makes this model work at scale.
Sets quantity and negotiates revenue share in Collective
Roaster ships direct to subscriber. Order is fulfilled using the normal fulfillment process
Images, pricing & variants flow into curator’s Shopify catalog
Order is synced to Shopify and Collective routes each order to the roaster for fulfillment
Curator writes campaign copy and schedules the drop
Subscribers reply to buy the offer. Payments captured & orders created instantly.
The curator never touches inventory. The roaster ships direct to the subscriber.
Fellow never touches inventory. Every bag ships directly from the roaster to the subscriber. This seamless dropshipping model is what allows Fellow to run high-frequency drops with dozens of roaster partners without scaling operational complexity — each new partnership follows the same pattern. And because the only requirement for vendors is a Shopify store, the barrier to entry stays low.
Want the full playbook? Read how curator brands combine Shopify Collective with text-to-buy.
The Numbers Speak for Themselves
Since switching to AudienceTap, Fellow’s Drops program has become one of the highest-converting text commerce programs in the industry.
6.2%
Conversion rate
vs 0.12% for standard SMS campaigns
$1.94
Earned per message sent
vs $0.13 email and $0.16 traditional SMS
32x
Return on investment
3x
More spend
Drops subscribers vs average customers
“The stickiness of our Fellow Drops program underscores how successful it is. Subscribers aren’t just one-and-done. They keep coming back — buying 5, 10, or even 20 drops. They’re purchasing our gear too — more often and in larger amounts than other customers.”
“The AudienceTap team goes above and beyond with their support. We regularly consult with them on advanced strategies. Not only do they offer valuable insights but they’ll often jump in to assist with implementation — they’ve even built out custom features to better help us achieve our goals. It’s like they are an extension of our internal team!”
Features That Power Fellow Drops
Text-to-Buy
Customers claim weekly coffee drops by replying to a text. No links, no carts, no checkout pages.
QuickCarts
Streamlined checkout for first-time buyers with stored payment for frictionless future drops.
Signup Forms
Branded signup forms that grow the Drops subscriber list across web, email, and social.
Automations
Automated welcome series, post-purchase flows, and drop reminders that run without manual work.
2-Way Texting
Direct conversations with subscribers for support, order questions, and building community.
More Case Studies
See how other brands are driving revenue with AudienceTap.
Tinker Coffee Co.
Specialty Coffee Roaster
8.6%
Conversion rate
$1.93
Earned per message
13.9x
ROI
Morgan Julia Designs
Needlepoint Designer and DTC Brand
2.10%
Conversion rate
$1.15
Earned per message
31.1x
ROI
Ready to see if AudienceTap is right for you?
Try a live demo on your phone
Enter your number to experience a Text-to-Buy flow firsthand.
Speak to an expert
Get a free 1-on-1 consultation with personalized setup recommendations for your brand.
